Is professional sport sustainable?

There is no doubt that professional sport in the twenty first century is about money, only creating wealth for those involved.

In December 2002 the Australian-born Rupert Murdoch, owner of News Corporation, wrote a very interesting column on his thoughts about professional sport as we knew it then. He was critical of the way professional sport was being managed and its economic demands on society. His punchline was that it was difficult to see sport surviving the professional era. This was interesting coming from a man who had a vast investment in professional sport through his media empire.

At first I thought he was being hard on professional sport, but as the years have passed there is no doubt that there are signs he could be correct and that professional sport is becoming a monster in certain areas. The honour of playing for your country or province and representing your community no longer exists today. Communities and fans today are irrelevant in professional sport as it is about creating wealth for players and team owners and television companies’ profits.

Rugby in the Southern Hemisphere is a good example of the problems that the professional era has created. Collectively South Africa, Australia and New Zealand have in excess of a thousand players playing in the United Kingdom, Europe and Japan. Especially South Africa and Australia have been stripped of their player base by these clubs and the warning signs are starting to show in these two proud rugby-playing nations.

Quality rugby players are produced in the Southern Hemisphere, but the commercial rewards are in the Northern Hemisphere. With no restrictions in place on foreign players, these clubs have and will continue to raid the Southern Hemisphere for players.  This will result in rugby, as we know it, being compromised in these countries to the detriment of the global game. There have been eight Rugby World Cups and the Southern Hemisphere teams have won seven of them. The current dispensation is not sustainable and healthy for the future of rugby.

Cricket is professionally better controlled by the International Cricket Council’s regulations. However, there are nearly fifty foreign cricketers playing county cricket by means of British or European Union passports and the controversial Kolpak policy, but are not qualified to play for England. Once again the drain of players is driven commercially because the Northern Hemisphere cricket industry has more money than their counterparts in the Southern Hemisphere.

In football the Barclays Premiership in England is also a good example of the influx of overseas players driven mainly by commercial needs. Once again this is detrimental to the English-born players and the national team. However, the clubs have kept their historical identities of well over a hundred years old and this has retained community interest in the teams.

There is no doubt that professional sport in the twenty first century is about money, only creating wealth for those involved. Only time will tell if Rupert Murdoch is a visionary or not.



Bookmark the permalink.

Comments are closed.